FRUIT FLY (Oneworld Publications 2026) by Josh Silver is one of the most interesting books I’ve read all year. If Baby Reindeer, Barton Fink, A Little Life and Yellowface all had a lovechild, FRUIT FLY would be it. This darkly comic satire is a very meta examination of stories, writing, ambition, success, source material and subject matter. Propulsive, vibrant, compelling, deliciously black, sharp, witty, human and profound, FRUIT FLY takes the very best and the very worst of novel writing and shifts the kaleidoscope to give readers a bird’s eye view of all that is happening.
The surface story is simple enough: Malloy Maddox published a bestseller seven years ago but has been thwarted by ‘writer’s block’ ever since. She has no idea what to write, or how. But she’s done it before; surely she can do it again? She is advised to ‘Go Gay, Go Dark and Go Sad’ – all the emotions that will pull at the heartstrings of her publisher and potential readers. But how? She is a ridiculously privileged white woman who wants for nothing. She has a beautiful house, a loving husband successful in his own career, and all the money she wants to spend decorating her home and intimate spaces to be as calm and serene as they like. How on earth is she supposed to plumb the depths of the dark underbelly of life?
Then she meets Leo, a young man in his twenties sleeping rough, a drug and alcohol addict who funds his addictions through sex with men, usually through chem-parties, or raging orgies fuelled by a dangerous cocktail of illegal drugs and highly promiscuous and sometimes fatal sexual misadventures. He’s vulnerable but also enigmatic and unusual. He’s exactly what Mallory has been looking for; exactly what she needs to write a story. HIS story. Which she will pass off as HER story. Leo is the perfect inspiration.
Only Leo doesn’t realise he’s being used or manipulated. He thinks Mallory really wants to help him get out from under the cycle of abuse and addiction which is now his norm. And what Mallory doesn’t realise is that perhaps Leo is smarter than she gives him credit for. Perhaps he has his own agenda. Maybe SHE will be the one caught in his web of deceit and lies.
How far will she go to produce the story she knows she was born to write? How far will Leo go to stay alive?
FRUIT FLY is such a fascinating book on so many levels. It is almost a mythological fable about the ethics of who gets to write whose stories. It is a writer writing about writing, writing a story about a writer writing. Very meta.
The part in the novel where the meaning of the title becomes obvious is perfectly prosed and subsequently forms an image that represents the entire book.
On the surface, this novel trundles along at a pedestrian pace, easy to read, and it seems we know what’s coming. We are mistaken. While there are no huge thriller plot twists, there are certainly more than enough shifts in the kaleidoscope to unsettle the reader, remind us that we are not in control of the story (and nor perhaps are Mallory or Leo). The issue of coercive control seeps in subtly and insidiously (much like real life). Especially towards the end of the novel, there are some definite moments of slow realisation or an abrupt change in tenor when we realise what we have thought all along is nothing like what is actually happening.
Narrated by both Leo and Mallory, we get both perspectives. But is either of them a reliable narrator? Leo is blunt, raw, visceral, poetic, street-smart, vulnerable and indulges in extremely risky behaviour. His narration is truncated, punchy and vital. Mallory is more languid and resolved, her situation is steady and reliable, her goals (to publish another bestseller!) might seem less important than Leo’s aim to stay alive each day. But both characters have wants and needs. Both are hamstrung by circumstances and a lack of opportunities. Both have complicated relationships with their families.
Both are desperate in their own way. The question is, how desperate is Mallory to achieve success? How desperate is Leo to survive? And will their goals ultimately align, or will one or the other (or both) be destroyed in the process?
FRUIT FLY is funny, intelligent, clever, witty, darkly humorous and compelling. A sharp and brutal read exploring the innermost psyche of each character, pulling it apart to examine it under the microscope, and laying the viscera out on the table for all to see. This novel will make you think. Unforgettable.